New Energy Efficient Way to Heat and Cool Buildings

By Kyleigh Marcotte and Andrew Trudel

August 2018

Earth tubes are a new and viable way to reduce the amount of energy needed to heat and cool a building.

Researchers with Natural Resources Canada recently analyzed the effectiveness of earth tube heat exchanger systems. Considered a passive geothermal technology, earth tube exchangers enable the transfer of ground source energy to heat or cool a building while using its existing ventilation system. The goal of this project is to explore alternative ways to make commercial and residential buildings’ heating systems more energy efficient.

Earth Tubes

Earth tubes are underground pipes buried beneath the frost line, the maximum depth within the soil where groundwater is expected to freeze. The frost line depth varies depending on the climatic conditions of a region.

Made of concrete, steel and/or plastic, earth tubes are used to condition outside ventilation air as it is pulled into a building. The temperature of the air drawn through pipes is moderated by the surrounding earth which is colder than the outdoor air in summer and warmer in the winter months. The air is then brought to ambient indoor temperatures by the building’s existing heating and cooling system.

“The addition of earth tubes to a building’s temperature control system could significantly reduce the need for certain kinds of ventilation air heating and cooling,” says Michel Tardif, Research Engineer and Project Leader with CanmetENERGY, a branch of Natural Resources Canada. In fact, results from a recent field study conducted in Toronto, Ontario indicated that earth tubes can warm winter air by as much as 14.3°C and cool summer air by about 6.8°C.

Other Benefits of Earth Tubes

Energy efficiency is not the only advantage of using earth-to-air heat exchange systems such as earth tubes. They also require minimal maintenance and have lower operational costs than traditional temperature control systems. Additionally, they are effective in reducing the use of fossil fuels and the release of greenhouse gas emissions from buildings making them environmentally-friendly.

Earth Tube Guidelines

“We’re currently working to validate our research model with results from a building located on the Scarborough campus of the University of Toronto, which has one of the largest earth tube systems in Canada,” says Michel. This research will lead to published design guidelines, since no well-defined parameters currently exist for earth tubes. These guidelines will help accelerate the adoption of earth tubes in buildings across the country.

Organizations across North America that are looking for new ways to improve the energy efficiency of their buildings and reduce operational costs have expressed an interest in the results of CanmetENERGY’s earth tubes research.

Earth tubes offer a sustainable alternative to reducing the use of conventional heating and cooling systems while producing clean, renewable, and affordable energy. Since building energy consumption accounts for about 15 percent of Canada’s greenhouse gas emissions, the more energy efficient buildings we have, the better it is for our environment.

For more information, visit the Natural Resources Canada Web site